论文检索

输入标题、作者或关键词,从 2,893 篇学术成果中精准定位

会议来源 全部会议

机器学习与综合 AI

自然语言处理

计算机视觉

数据挖掘与 Web

多媒体与图形学

未选择时检索全部会议
支持跨会议组合检索,PDF 均跳转至官方来源
2,893篇论文匹配“Neural Network Optimization”
第 25 / 145 页

Theory · Learning Theory

Alberto Bassi, Marco Baity-Jesi, Aurelien Lucchi, Carlo Albert, Emanuele Francazi

The statistical properties of deep neural networks (DNNs) at initialization play an important role to comprehend their trainability and the intrinsic architectural biases they possess before data exposure. Well established mean-field (MF) theories have uncovered that the distribution of parameters of randomly initialized networks strongly influences the behavior of the gradients, dictating whether they explode or vanish. Recent work has showed that untrained DNNs also manifest an initial-guessing bias (IGB), in which large regions of the input space are assigned to a single class. In this work, we provide a theoretical proof that links IGB to previous MF theories for a vast class of DNNs, showing that efficient learning is tightly connected to a network’s prejudice towards a specific class. This connection leads to a counterintuitive conclusion: the initialization that optimizes trainability is systematically biased rather than neutral.

General Machine Learning · Representation Learning

Debopam Sanyal, Anantharaman Iyer, Alind Khare, Trisha Jain, Akshay Jajoo, Myungjin Lee, James Kerce, Alexey Tumanov

Given the wide range of deployment targets, flexible model selection is essential for optimizing performance within a given compute budget. Recent work demonstrates that stitching pretrained models within a model family enables cost-effective interpolation of the accuracy-efficiency tradeoff space. Stitching transforms intermediate activations from one pretrained model into another, producing a new interpolated stitched network. Such networks provide a pool of deployment options along the accuracy-efficiency spectrum. However, existing stitching approaches often yield suboptimal tradeoffs and lack generalizability, as they primarily rely on heuristics to select stitch configurations. We argue that constructing improved accuracy-efficiency tradeoffs requires explicitly capturing and leveraging the similarity between pretrained models being stitched. To this end, we introduce KLAS, a novel stitch selection framework that automates and generalizes stitch selection across model families by leveraging KL divergence between intermediate representations. KLAS identifies the most promising binary stitches from the $\mathcal{O}(k^2n^2)$ possibilities for $k$ pretrained models of depth $n$. Through comprehensive experiments, we demonstrate that KLAS improves the accuracy-efficiency curve of stitched models at the same finetuning cost as baselines. KLAS achieves up to $1.21\%$ higher ImageNet-1K top-1 accuracy at the same computational cost, or maintains accuracy with a $1.33\times$ reduction in FLOPs.

Deep Learning · Graph Neural Networks

Guanjun Wang, Binwu Wang, Jiaming Ma, Zhengyang Zhou, Pengkun Wang, Xu Wang, Yang Wang

Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have advanced graph classification, yet they remain vulnerable to graph-level imbalance, encompassing class imbalance and topological imbalance. To address both types of imbalance in a unified manner, we propose UniImb, a Unified framework for Imbalanced graph classification. Specifically, UniImb first captures multi-scale topological features and enhances data diversity via learnable personalized graph perturbations. It then employs a dynamic balanced prototype module to learn representative prototypes from graph instances, improving the quality of graph representations. Concurrently, a prototype load-balancing optimization term mitigates dominance by majority samples to equalize sample influence during training. We justify these design choices theoretically using the Information Bottleneck principle. Extensive experiments on 19 datasets-including a large-scale imbalanced air pollution graph dataset AirGraph released by us and 23 baselines demonstrate that UniImb has achieved dominant performance across various imbalanced scenarios. Our code is available at GitHub.

Optimization · Everything Else

Igor Smit, Yaoxin Wu, Pavel Troubil, Yingqian Zhang, Wim P.M. Nuijten

Neural combinatorial optimization (NCO) has made significant advances in applying deep learning techniques to efficiently and effectively solve single-objective flexible job shop scheduling problems (FJSPs). However, the more practical multi-objective FJSPs (MOFJSPs) remain underexplored, limiting the applicability of NCO in multi-criteria decision-making scenarios. In this paper, we propose a decomposition-based NCO method to solve MOFJSPs. We present the dual conditional attention network (DCAN), a neural network architecture that takes the objective preferences along with the problem instance, aiming to learn adaptable policies over the preferences. By decomposing an MOFJSP into a set of subproblems with different preferences, the learned DCAN policies generate a set of solutions that reflect the corresponding trade-offs. We customize the Proximal Policy Optimization algorithm based on decomposition to effectively train the policy network for multiple objectives and define the state and reward based on combinations of different objectives. Extensive results showcase that our approach outperforms traditional multi-objective optimization methods and generalizes well across diverse types of problem instances.

Theory · Probabilistic Methods

Nikos Tsikouras, Yorgos Pantis, Ioannis Mitliagkas, Christos Tzamos

Understanding the dynamics of feature learning in neural networks (NNs) remains a significant challenge. The work of (Mousavi-Hosseini et al., 2023) analyzes a multiple index teacher-student setting and shows that a two-layer student attains a low-rank structure in its first-layer weights when trained with stochastic gradient descent (SGD) and a strong regularizer. This structural property is known to reduce sample complexity of generalization. Indeed, in a second step, the same authors establish algorithm-specific learning guarantees under additional assumptions. In this paper, we focus exclusively on the structure discovery aspect and study it under weaker assumptions, more specifically: we allow (a) NNs of arbitrary size and depth, (b) with all parameters trainable, (c) under any smooth loss function, (d) tiny regularization, and (e) trained by any method that attains a second-order stationary point (SOSP), e.g. perturbed gradient descent (PGD). At the core of our approach is a key $\textit{derandomization}$ lemma, which states that optimizing the function $E_{x} \left[g_{\theta}(Wx + b)\right]$ converges to a point where $W = 0$, under mild conditions. The fundamental nature of this lemma directly explains structure discovery and has immediate applications in other domains including an end-to-end approximation for MAXCUT, and computing Johnson-Lindenstrauss embeddings.

Deep Learning · Algorithms

Aleksandr Dremov, David Grangier, Angelos Katharopoulos, Awni Hannun

Quantization-aware training (QAT) is a leading technique for improving the accuracy of quantized neural networks. Previous work has shown that decomposing training into a full-precision (FP) phase followed by a QAT phase yields superior accuracy compared to QAT alone. However, the optimal allocation of compute between the FP and QAT phases remains unclear. We conduct extensive experiments with various compute budgets, QAT bit widths, and model sizes from 86.0M to 2.2B to investigate how different QAT durations impact final performance. We demonstrate that, contrary to previous findings, the loss-optimal ratio of QAT to FP training increases with the total amount of compute. Moreover, the optimal fraction can be accurately predicted for a wide range of model sizes and quantization widths using the tokens-per-parameter-byte statistic. From experimental data, we derive a loss scaling law that predicts both optimal QAT ratios and final model performance across different QAT/FP compute allocation strategies and QAT bit widths. We use the scaling law to make further predictions, which we verify experimentally, including which QAT bit width is optimal under a given memory constraint and how QAT accuracy with different bit widths compares to full-precision model accuracy. Additionally, we propose a novel cooldown and QAT fusion approach that performs learning rate decay jointly with quantization-aware training, eliminating redundant full-precision model updates and achieving significant compute savings. These findings provide practical insights into efficient QAT planning and enable the training of higher-quality quantized models with the same compute budget.

Deep Learning · Theory

Hong-Yi Wang, Di Luo, Tomaso Poggio, Isaac Chuang, Liu Ziyin

When training large-scale models, the performance typically scales with the number of parameters and the dataset size according to a slow power law. A fundamental theoretical and practical question is whether comparable performance can be achieved with significantly smaller models and substantially less data. In this work, we provide a positive and constructive answer. We prove that a generic permutation-invariant function of $d$ objects can be asymptotically compressed into a function of $\operatorname{polylog} d$ objects with vanishing error, which is proved to be the optimal compression rate. This theorem yields two key implications: (Ia) a large neural network can be compressed to polylogarithmic width while preserving its learning dynamics; (Ib) a large dataset can be compressed to polylogarithmic size while leaving the loss landscape of the corresponding model unchanged. Implication (Ia) directly establishes a proof of the dynamical lottery ticket hypothesis, which states that any ordinary network can be strongly compressed such that the learning dynamics and result remain unchanged. (Ib) shows that a neural scaling law of the form $L\sim d^{-\alpha}$ can be boosted to an arbitrarily fast power law decay, and ultimately to $\exp(-\alpha' \sqrt[m]{d})$.

Computer Vision · 3D Rendering & Reconstruction

Renjie Ding, Yaonan Wang, Min Liu, Jialin Zhu, Jiazheng Wang, Jiahao Zhao, Wenting Shen, Feixiang He, Xiang Chen

3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) has emerged as a powerful technique for real-time novel view synthesis. As an explicit representation optimized through gradient propagation among primitives, optimization widely accepted in deep neural networks (DNNs) is actually adopted in 3DGS, such as synchronous weight updating and Adam with the adaptive gradient. However, considering the physical significance and specific design in 3DGS, there are two overlooked details in the optimization of 3DGS: (i) update step coupling, which induces optimizer state rescaling and costly attribute updates outside the viewpoints, and (ii) gradient coupling in the moment, which may lead to under- or over-effective regularization. Nevertheless, such a complex coupling is under-explored. After revisiting the optimization of 3DGS, we take a step to decouple it and recompose the process into: Sparse Adam, Re-State Regularization and Decoupled Attribute Regularization. Taking a large number of experiments under the 3DGS and 3DGS-MCMC frameworks, our work provides a deeper understanding of these components. Finally, based on the empirical analysis, we re-design the optimization and propose AdamW-GS by re-coupling the beneficial components, under which better optimization efficiency and representation effectiveness are achieved simultaneously.

Reinforcement Learning · Planning

Xiaoyuan Cheng, Yiming Yang, Wei Jiang, Chenyang Yuan, Zhuo Sun, Yukun Hu

This paper studies how to achieve accurate modeling and effective control in stochastic nonlinear dynamics with multiple interacting objects. However, non-uniform interactions and random topologies make this task challenging. We address these challenges by proposing Graph Controllable Embeddings (GCE), a general framework to learn stochastic multi-object dynamics for linear control. Specifically, GCE is built on Hilbert space embeddings, allowing direct embedding of probability distributions of controlled stochastic dynamics into a reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS), which enables linear operations in its RKHS while retaining nonlinear expressiveness. We provide theoretical guarantees on the existence, convergence, and applicability of GCE. Notably, a mean field approximation technique is adopted to efficiently capture inter-object dependencies and achieves provably low sample complexity. By integrating graph neural networks, we construct data-dependent kernel features which are capable of adapting to dynamic interaction patterns and generalizing to even unseen topologies with only limited training instances. GCE scales seamlessly to multi-object systems of varying sizes and topologies. Leveraging the linearity of Hilbert spaces, GCE also supports simple yet effective control algorithms for synthesizing optimal sequences. Experiments on physical systems, robotics, and power grids validate GCE and demonstrate consistent performance improvement over various competitive embedding methods in both in-distribution and few-shot tests.

Deep Learning · Graph Neural Networks

Xiaobao Wang, Renda Han, Ronghao Fu, Di Jin

Federated Graph-level Clustering (FGC) offers a promising framework for analyzing distributed graph data while ensuring privacy protection. However, existing methods fail to simultaneously consider knowledge heterogeneity across intra- and inter-client, and still attempt to share as much knowledge as possible, resulting in consensus failure in the server. To solve these issues, we propose a novel **F**ederated **G**raph-level **C**lustering **N**etwork with **D**ual **K**nowledge **S**eparation (FGCN-DKS). The core idea is to decouple differentiated subgraph patterns and optimize them separately on the client, and then leverage cluster-oriented patterns to guide personalized knowledge aggregation on the server. Specifically, on the client, we separate personalized subgraphs and cluster-oriented subgraphs for each graph. Then the former are retained locally for further refinement of the clustering process, while pattern digests are extracted from the latter for uploading to the server. On the server, we calculate the relation of inter-cluster patterns to adaptively aggregate cluster-oriented prototypes and parameters. Finally, the server generates personalized guidance signals for each cluster of clients, which are then fed back to local clients to enhance overall clustering performance. Extensive experiments on multiple graph benchmark datasets have proven the superiority of the proposed FGCN-DKS over the SOTA methods.

Applications · Time Series

Ruirui Wang, Yanke Li, Manuel Günther, Diego Paez-Granados

Healthcare data, such as Intensive Care Unit (ICU) records, comprise heterogeneous multivariate time series sampled at irregular intervals with pervasive missingness. However, clinical applications demand predictive models that are both accurate and interpretable. We present our Graph Attention-based Relational Learning for Intensive Care (GARLIC) model, a novel neural network architecture that imputes missing data through a learnable exponential-decay encoder, captures inter-sensor dependencies via time-lagged summary graphs, and fuses global patterns with cross-dimensional sequential attention. All attention weights and graph edges are learned end-to-end to serve as built-in observation-, signal-, and edge-level explanations. To reconcile auxiliary reconstruction and primary classification objectives, we developed an alternating decoupled optimization scheme that stabilizes training. On three ICU benchmarks (PhysioNet 2012 \& 2019, MIMIC-III), GARLIC sets the new state of the art in outcome prediction, significantly improving AUROC and AUPRC over best-performing baselines at comparable computational cost. Ablation studies confirm the contribution of each module, and feature-removal trials validate the fidelity of importance attribution through a monotonic performance drop (full > top 50\% > random 50\% > bottom 50\%). Real-time case studies demonstrate actionable risk warnings with transparent explanations, marking a significant advance toward accurate, explainable deep learning for irregularly sampled ICU time series data. Moreover, we demonstrated GARLIC's superiority in data imputation and classification on various time-series datasets beyond the ICU domain, showing its generalizability and applicability to broader tasks.

Optimization · Learning for Optimization

Abhinav Moudgil

Learned optimization has emerged as a promising alternative to hand-crafted optimizers, with the potential to discover stronger learned update rules that enable faster, hyperparameter-free training of neural networks. A critical element for practically useful learned optimizers, that can be used off-the-shelf after meta-training, is strong meta-generalization: the ability to apply the optimizers to new tasks. Recent state-of-the-art work in learned optimizers, VeLO (Metz et al., 2022), requires a large number of highly diverse meta-training tasks along with massive computational resources, 4000 TPU months, to achieve meta-generalization. This makes further improvements to such learned optimizers impractical. In this work, we identify several key elements in learned optimizer architectures and meta-training procedures that can lead to strong meta-generalization. We also propose evaluation metrics to reliably assess quantitative performance of an optimizer at scale on a set of evaluation tasks. Our proposed approach, Celo, makes a significant leap in improving the meta-generalization performance of learned optimizers and also outperforms tuned state-of-the-art optimizers on a diverse set of out-of-distribution tasks, despite being meta-trained for just 24 GPU hours.

General Machine Learning · Representation Learning

Federico Errica, Henrik Christiansen, Viktor Zaverkin, Mathias Niepert, Francesco Alesiani

For almost 70 years, researchers have typically selected the width of neural networks’ layers either manually or through automated hyperparameter tuning methods such as grid search and, more recently, neural architecture search. This paper challenges the status quo by introducing an easy-to-use technique to learn an \textit{unbounded} width of a neural network's layer \textit{during training}. The method jointly optimizes the width and the parameters of each layer via standard backpropagation. We apply the technique to a broad range of data domains such as tables, images, text, sequences, and graphs, showing how the width adapts to the task's difficulty. A by product of our width learning approach is the easy truncation of the trained network at virtually zero cost, achieving a smooth trade-off between performance and compute resources. Alternatively, one can dynamically compress the network until performances do not degrade. In light of recent foundation models trained on large datasets, requiring billions of parameters and where hyper-parameter tuning is unfeasible due to huge training costs, our approach introduces a viable alternative for width learning.

General Machine Learning · Representation Learning

Yue Wu, Jialin Zhao, Carlo Vittorio Cannistraci

With the advent of the neural network era, traditional machine learning methods have increasingly been overshadowed. Nevertheless, continuing research on the role of geometry for learning in data science is crucial to envision and understand new principles behind the design of efficient machine learning. Linear classifiers are favored in certain tasks due to their reduced susceptibility to overfitting and their ability to provide interpretable decision boundaries. However, achieving both scalability and high predictive performance in linear classification remains a persistent challenge. Here, we propose a theoretical framework named geometric discriminant analysis (GDA). GDA includes the family of linear classifiers that can be expressed as a function of a centroid discriminant basis (CDB0) - the connection line between two centroids - adjusted by geometric corrections under different constraints. We demonstrate that linear discriminant analysis (LDA) is a subcase of the GDA theoretical framework, and we show its convergence to CDB0 under certain conditions. Then, based on the GDA framework, we propose an efficient linear classifier named centroid discriminant analysis (CDA) which is defined as a special case of GDA under a 2D plane geometric constraint. CDA training is initialized starting from CDB0 and involves the iterative calculation of new adjusted centroid discriminant lines whose optimal rotations on the associated 2D planes are searched via Bayesian optimization. CDA has good scalability (quadratic time complexity) which is lower than LDA and support vector machine (SVM) (cubic complexity). Results on 27 real datasets across classification tasks of standard images, medical images and chemical properties, offer empirical evidence that CDA outperforms other linear methods such as LDA, SVM and logistic regression (LR) in terms of scalability, performance and stability. Furthermore, we show that linear CDA can be generalized to nonlinear CDA via kernel method, demonstrating improvements on the linear version with tests on three challenging datasets of images and chemical data. GDA's general validity as a new theoretical framework may inspire the design of new classifiers under the definition of different geometric constraints, paving the way towards a deeper understanding of the role of geometry in learning from data.

Optimization · Learning for Optimization

Dohyun Bu, Yujung Byun, JONGSEOK LEE

Physics-Informed Neural Networks (PINNs) have emerged as a powerful tool for solving PDEs, yet training is difficult due to a multi-objective loss that couples PDE residuals, initial/boundary conditions, and auxiliary physics terms. Existing remedies often yield infeasible scaling factors or conflicting update directions, resulting in degraded performance. In this paper, we show that training PINNs requires jointly considering feasible scaling factors and a non-conflict direction. Through a geometric analysis of per-loss gradients, we define the $\textit{harmonized cone}$ as the intersection of their primal and dual cones, which characterizes directions that are simultaneously feasible and non-conflicting. Building on this, we propose $HARMONIC$ (HARMONIzed Cone gradient descent), a training procedure that computes updates within the harmonized cone by leveraging the Double Description method to aggregate extreme rays. Theoretically, we establish convergence guarantees in nonconvex settings and prove the existence of a nontrivial harmonized cone. Across standard PDE benchmarks, $HARMONIC$ generally outperforms state-of-the-art methods while ensuring feasible and non-conflict updates.

Deep Learning · Generative Models and Autoencoders

Mikhail Persiianov, Jiawei Chen, Petr Mokrov, Alexander Tyurin, Evgeny Burnaev, Aleksandr Korotin

Learning population dynamics involves recovering the underlying process that governs particle evolution, given evolutionary snapshots of samples at discrete time points. Recent methods frame this as an energy minimization problem in probability space and leverage the celebrated JKO scheme for efficient time discretization. In this work, we introduce ``iJKOnet``, an approach that combines the JKO framework with inverse optimization techniques to learn population dynamics. Our method relies on a conventional *end-to-end* adversarial training procedure and does not require restrictive architectural choices, e.g., input-convex neural networks. We establish theoretical guarantees for our methodology and demonstrate improved performance over prior JKO-based methods.

Optimization · Everything Else

Paul Caillon, Erwan Fagnou, Blaise Delattre, Alexandre Allauzen

Deep neural networks rely on backpropagation (BP) for optimization, but its strictly sequential backward pass hinders parallelism and scalability. Direct Feedback Alignment (DFA) has been proposed as a promising approach for parallel learning of deep neural networks, relying on fixed random projections to enable layer-wise parallel updates, but fails on deep convolutional networks, and performs poorly on modern transformer architectures. We introduce GrAPE (Gradient-Aligned Projected Error), a hybrid feedback-alignment method that (i) estimates rank-1 Jacobians via forward-mode JVPs and (ii) aligns each layer’s feedback matrix by minimizing a local cosine-alignment loss. To curb drift in very deep models, GrAPE performs infrequent BP anchor steps on a single mini-batch, preserving mostly parallel updates. We show that the forward-gradient estimator has strictly positive expected cosine with the true Jacobian. We relate this estimator-level guarantee to a standard stochastic-approximation result under a positive expected-cosine condition on the update direction, providing theoretical support for GrAPE’s alignment objective. Empirically, GrAPE consistently outperforms prior alternatives to BP, enabling the training of modern architectures, closing a large fraction of the gap to BP while retaining layer-parallel updates for the vast majority of steps.

Applications · Neuroscience, Cognitive Science

Puria Radmard, Paul Bays, Máté Lengyel

Discovering the neural mechanisms underpinning cognition is one of the grand challenges of neuroscience. However, previous approaches for building models of recurrent neural network (RNN) dynamics that explain behaviour required iterative refinement of architectures and/or optimisation objectives, resulting in a piecemeal, and mostly heuristic, human-in-the-loop process. Here, we offer an alternative approach that automates the discovery of viable RNN mechanisms by explicitly training RNNs to reproduce behaviour, including the same characteristic errors and suboptimalities, that humans and animals produce in a cognitive task. Achieving this required two main innovations. First, as the amount of behavioural data that can be collected in experiments is often too limited to train RNNs, we use a non-parametric generative model of behavioural responses to produce surrogate data for training RNNs. Second, to capture all relevant statistical aspects of the data, rather than a limited number of hand-picked low-order moments as in previous moment-matching-based approaches, we developed a novel diffusion model-based approach for training RNNs. To showcase the potential of our approach, we chose a visual working memory task as our test-bed, as behaviour in this task is well known to produce response distributions that are patently multimodal (due to so-called swap errors). The resulting network dynamics correctly predicted previously reported qualitative features of neural data recorded in macaques. Importantly, these results were not possible to obtain with more traditional approaches, i.e., when only a limited set of behavioural signatures (rather than the full richness of behavioural response distributions) were fitted, or when RNNs were trained for task optimality (instead of reproducing behaviour). Our approach also yields novel predictions about the mechanism of swap errors, which can be readily tested in experiments. These results suggest that fitting RNNs to rich patterns of behaviour provides a powerful way to automatically discover the neural network dynamics supporting important cognitive functions.

Brandon Annesi, Dario Bocchi, Chiara Cammarota

High-dimensional non-convex loss landscapes play a central role in the theory of Machine Learning. Gaining insight into how these landscapes interact with gradient-based optimization methods, even in relatively simple models, can shed light on this enigmatic feature of neural networks. In this work, we will focus on a prototypical simple learning problem, which generalizes the Phase Retrieval inference problem by allowing the exploration of overparametrized settings. Using techniques from field theory, we analyze the spectrum of the Hessian at initialization and identify a Baik–Ben Arous–Péché (BBP) transition in the amount of data that separates regimes where the initialization is informative or uninformative about a planted signal of a teacher-student setup. Crucially, we demonstrate how overparameterization can "bend" the loss landscape, shifting the transition point, even reaching the information-theoretic weak-recovery threshold in the large overparameterization limit, while also altering its qualitative nature. We distinguish between continuous and discontinuous BBP transitions and support our analytical predictions with simulations, examining how they compare to the finite-N behavior. In the case of discontinuous BBP transitions strong finite-N corrections allow the retrieval of information at a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) smaller than the predicted BBP transition. In these cases we provide estimates for a new lower SNR threshold that marks the point at which initialization becomes entirely uninformative.

Theory · Learning Theory

Brandon Annesi, Dario Bocchi, Chiara Cammarota

High-dimensional non-convex loss landscapes play a central role in the theory of Machine Learning. Gaining insight into how these landscapes interact with gradient-based optimization methods, even in relatively simple models, can shed light on this enigmatic feature of neural networks. In this work, we will focus on a prototypical simple learning problem, which generalizes the Phase Retrieval inference problem by allowing the exploration of overparametrized settings. Using techniques from field theory, we analyze the spectrum of the Hessian at initialization and identify a Baik–Ben Arous–Péché (BBP) transition in the amount of data that separates regimes where the initialization is informative or uninformative about a planted signal of a teacher-student setup. Crucially, we demonstrate how overparameterization can "bend" the loss landscape, shifting the transition point, even reaching the information-theoretic weak-recovery threshold in the large overparameterization limit, while also altering its qualitative nature. We distinguish between continuous and discontinuous BBP transitions and support our analytical predictions with simulations, examining how they compare to the finite-N behavior. In the case of discontinuous BBP transitions strong finite-N corrections allow the retrieval of information at a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) smaller than the predicted BBP transition. In these cases we provide estimates for a new lower SNR threshold that marks the point at which initialization becomes entirely uninformative.