论文检索

Optimization · Large Scale, Parallel and Distributed

Diba Hashemi, Lie He, Martin Jaggi

Collaborative learning is an important tool to train multiple clients more effectively by enabling communication among clients. Identifying helpful clients, however, presents challenging and often introduces significant overhead. In this paper, we model **client-selection** and **model-training** as two interconnected optimization problems, proposing a novel bilevel optimization problem for collaborative learning.We introduce **CoBo**, a *scalable* and *elastic*, SGD-type alternating optimization algorithm that efficiently addresses these problem with theoretical convergence guarantees. Empirically, **CoBo** achieves superior performance, surpassing popular personalization algorithms by 9.3% in accuracy on a task with high heterogeneity, involving datasets distributed among 80 clients.

Tianshu Chu, Dachuan Xu, Wei Yao, Jin Zhang

While stochastic bilevel optimization methods have been extensively studied for addressing large-scale nested optimization problems in machine learning, it remains an open question whether the optimal complexity bounds for solving bilevel optimization are the same as those in single-level optimization. Our main result resolves this question: SPABA, an adaptation of the PAGE method for nonconvex optimization in (Li et al., 2021) to the bilevel setting, can achieve optimal sample complexity in both the finite-sum and expectation settings. We show the optimality of SPABA by proving that there is no gap in complexity analysis between stochastic bilevel and single-level optimization when implementing PAGE. Notably, as indicated by the results of (Dagréou et al., 2022), there might exist a gap in complexity analysis when implementing other stochastic gradient estimators, like SGD and SAGA. In addition to SPABA, we propose several other single-loop stochastic bilevel algorithms, that either match or improve the state-of-the-art sample complexity results, leveraging our convergence rate and complexity analysis. Numerical experiments demonstrate the superior practical performance of the proposed methods.

Xiaochuan Gong, Jie Hao, Mingrui Liu

This paper studies the problem of stochastic bilevel optimization where the upper-level function is nonconvex with potentially unbounded smoothness and the lower-level function is strongly convex. This problem is motivated by meta-learning applied to sequential data, such as text classification using recurrent neural networks, where the smoothness constant of the upper-level loss function scales linearly with the gradient norm and can be potentially unbounded. Existing algorithm crucially relies on the nested loop design, which requires significant tuning efforts and is not practical. In this paper, we address this issue by proposing a Single Loop bIlevel oPtimizer (SLIP). The proposed algorithm first updates the lower-level variable by a few steps of stochastic gradient descent, and then simultaneously updates the upper-level variable by normalized stochastic gradient descent with momentum and the lower-level variable by stochastic gradient descent. Under standard assumptions, we show that our algorithm finds an $\epsilon$-stationary point within $\widetilde{O}(1/\epsilon^4)$[Here $\widetilde{O}(\cdot)$ compresses logarithmic factors of $1/\epsilon$ and $1/\delta$, where $\delta\in(0,1)$ denotes the failure probability.] oracle calls of stochastic gradient or Hessian-vector product, both in expectation and with high probability. This complexity result is nearly optimal up to logarithmic factors without mean-square smoothness of the stochastic gradient oracle. Our proof relies on (i) a refined characterization and control of the lower-level variable and (ii) establishing a novel connection between bilevel optimization and stochastic optimization under distributional drift. Our experiments on various tasks show that our algorithm significantly outperforms strong baselines in bilevel optimization.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Feihu Huang

Bilevel optimization is widely applied in many machine learning tasks such as hyper-parameter learning, meta learning and reinforcement learning. Although many algorithms recently have been developed to solve the bilevel optimization problems, they generally rely on the (strongly) convex lower-level problems. More recently, some methods have been proposed to solve the nonconvex-PL bilevel optimization problems, where their upper-level problems are possibly nonconvex, and their lower-level problems are also possibly nonconvex while satisfying Polyak-Łojasiewicz (PL) condition. However, these methods still have a high convergence complexity or a high computation complexity such as requiring compute expensive Hessian/Jacobian matrices and its inverses. In the paper, thus, we propose an efficient Hessian/Jacobian-free method (i.e., HJFBiO) with the optimal convergence complexity to solve the nonconvex-PL bilevel problems. Theoretically, under some mild conditions, we prove that our HJFBiO method obtains an optimal convergence rate of $O(\frac{1}{T})$, where $T$ denotes the number of iterations, and has an optimal gradient complexity of $O(\epsilon^{-1})$ in finding an $\epsilon$-stationary solution. We conduct some numerical experiments on the bilevel PL game and hyper-representation learning task to demonstrate efficiency of our proposed method.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Jeongyeol Kwon, Dohyun Kwon, Hanbaek Lyu

We consider the problem of finding stationary points in Bilevel optimization when the lower-level problem is unconstrained and strongly convex. The problem has been extensively studied in recent years; the main technical challenge is to keep track of lower-level solutions $y^*(x)$ in response to the changes in the upper-level variables $x$. Subsequently, all existing approaches tie their analyses to a genie algorithm that knows lower-level solutions and, therefore, need not query any points far from them. We consider a dual question to such approaches: suppose we have an oracle, which we call $y^*$-aware, that returns an $O(\epsilon)$-estimate of the lower-level solution, in addition to first-order gradient estimators *locally unbiased* within the $\Theta(\epsilon)$-ball around $y^*(x)$. We study the complexity of finding stationary points with such an $y^*$-aware oracle: we propose a simple first-order method that converges to an $\epsilon$ stationary point using $O(\epsilon^{-6}), O(\epsilon^{-4})$ access to first-order $y^*$-aware oracles. Our upper bounds also apply to standard unbiased first-order oracles, improving the best-known complexity of first-order methods by $O(\epsilon)$ with minimal assumptions. We then provide the matching $\Omega(\epsilon^{-6})$, $\Omega(\epsilon^{-4})$ lower bounds without and with an additional smoothness assumption, respectively. Our results imply that any approach that simulates an algorithm with an $y^*$-aware oracle must suffer the same lower bounds.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Yutong He, Jie Hu, Xinmeng Huang, Songtao Lu, Bin Wang, Kun Yuan

Stochastic bilevel optimization tackles challenges involving nested optimization structures. Its fast-growing scale nowadays necessitates efficient distributed algorithms. In conventional distributed bilevel methods, each worker must transmit full-dimensional stochastic gradients to the server every iteration, leading to significant communication overhead and thus hindering efficiency and scalability. To resolve this issue, we introduce the **first** family of distributed bilevel algorithms with communication compression. The primary challenge in algorithmic development is mitigating bias in hypergradient estimation caused by the nested structure. We first propose C-SOBA, a simple yet effective approach with unbiased compression and provable linear speedup convergence. However, it relies on strong assumptions on bounded gradients. To address this limitation, we explore the use of moving average, error feedback, and multi-step compression in bilevel optimization, resulting in a series of advanced algorithms with relaxed assumptions and improved convergence properties. Numerical experiments show that our compressed bilevel algorithms can achieve $10\times$ reduction in communication overhead without severe performance degradation.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Han Shen, Zhuoran Yang, Tianyi Chen

Bilevel optimization has been recently applied to many machine learning tasks. However, their applications have been restricted to the supervised learning setting, where static objective functions with benign structures are considered. But bilevel problems such as incentive design, inverse reinforcement learning (RL), and RL from human feedback (RLHF) are often modeled as dynamic objective functions that go beyond the simple static objective structures, which pose significant challenges of using existing bilevel solutions. To tackle this new class of bilevel problems, we introduce the first principled algorithmic framework for solving bilevel RL problems through the lens of penalty formulation. We provide theoretical studies of the problem landscape and its penalty-based (policy) gradient algorithms. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our algorithms via simulations in the Stackelberg game and RLHF.

Miscellaneous Aspects of Machine Learning · Transfer, Multitask and Meta-learning

Pengwei Xing, Songtao Lu, Han Yu

Neuro-symbolic learning (NSL) models complex symbolic rule patterns into latent variable distributions by neural networks, which reduces rule search space and generates unseen rules to improve downstream task performance. Centralized NSL learning involves directly acquiring data from downstream tasks, which is not feasible for federated learning (FL). To address this limitation, we shift the focus from such a one-to-one interactive neuro-symbolic paradigm to one-to-many Federated Neuro-Symbolic Learning framework (FedNSL) with latent variables as the FL communication medium. Built on the basis of our novel reformulation of the NSL theory, FedNSL is capable of identifying and addressing rule distribution heterogeneity through a simple and effective Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence constraint on rule distribution applicable under the FL setting. It further theoretically adjusts variational expectation maximization (V-EM) to reduce the rule search space across domains. This is the first incorporation of distribution-coupled bilevel optimization into FL. Extensive experiments based on both synthetic and real-world data demonstrate significant advantages of FedNSL compared to five state-of-the-art methods. It outperforms the best baseline by 17% and 29% in terms of unbalanced average training accuracy and unseen average testing accuracy, respectively.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Wanyun Xie, Fabian Latorre, Kimon Antonakopoulos, Thomas Pethick, Volkan Cevher

This paper rethinks Sharpness-Aware Minimization (SAM), which is originally formulated as a zero-sum game where the weights of a network and a bounded perturbation try to minimize/maximize, respectively, the same differentiable loss. To fundamentally improve this design, we argue that SAM should instead be reformulated using the 0-1 loss. As a continuous relaxation, we follow the simple conventional approach where the minimizing (maximizing) player uses an upper bound (lower bound) surrogate to the 0-1 loss. This leads to a novel formulation of SAM as a bilevel optimization problem, dubbed as BiSAM. BiSAM with newly designed lower-bound surrogate loss indeed constructs stronger perturbation. Through numerical evidence, we show that BiSAM consistently results in improved performance when compared to the original SAM and variants, while enjoying similar computational complexity. Our code is available at https://github.com/LIONS-EPFL/BiSAM.

Yuhao Wu, Jiangchao Yao, Bo Han, Lina Yao, Tongliang Liu

While Positive-Unlabeled (PU) learning is vital in many real-world scenarios, its application to graph data still remains under-explored. We unveil that a critical challenge for PU learning on graph lies on the edge heterophily, which directly violates the $\textit{irreducibility assumption}$ for $\textit{Class-Prior Estimation}$ (class prior is essential for building PU learning algorithms) and degenerates the latent label inference on unlabeled nodes during classifier training. In response to this challenge, we introduce a new method, named $\textit{$\underline{G}$raph $\underline{P}$U Learning with $\underline{L}$abel Propagation Loss}$ (GPL). Specifically, GPL considers learning from PU nodes along with an intermediate heterophily reduction, which helps mitigate the negative impact of the heterophilic structure. We formulate this procedure as a bilevel optimization that reduces heterophily in the inner loop and efficiently learns a classifier in the outer loop. Extensive experiments across a variety of datasets have shown that GPL significantly outperforms baseline methods, confirming its effectiveness and superiority.

Liangliang Shi, Jack Fan, Junchi Yan

We propose to understand Contrastive Language-Image Pretraining model (CLIP) from the Optimal Transport (OT) perspective. Specifically, we show that training of CLIP is an embodiment of inverse OT and the adopted two InfoNCE losses in CLIP correspond to a special case of bilevel optimization of modified entropic OT. We then generalize the original CLIP loss to an OT-based loss family using variants of Regularized OT (e.g. Fused Gromov OT, unbalanced OT, etc.), and demonstrate their superior performance on public datasets for both image and text downstream tasks. We also rethink the inference stage of CLIP by using the tool of OT, and propose to adopt the fused Gromov OT for (zero-shot) classification, in which the prediction is based on the graph representation whereby images and texts are nodes for graph matching. By our new technique, we show how to generalize zero-shot classification to other more flexible zero-shot tasks with competitive performance: long-tailed classification and selective classification. The former assumes the known prior distribution of labels, while in the latter case, only a subset of samples are asked to predict, yet with high prediction confidence.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Wanli Shi, Yi Chang, Bin Gu

Bilevel optimization (BO) has recently gained prominence in many machine learning applications due to its ability to capture the nested structure inherent in these problems. Recently, many hypergradient methods have been proposed as effective solutions for solving large-scale problems. However, current hypergradient methods for the lower-level constrained bilevel optimization (LCBO) problems need very restrictive assumptions, namely, where optimality conditions satisfy the differentiability and invertibility conditions, and lack a solid analysis of the convergence rate. What's worse, existing methods require either double-loop updates, which are sometimes less efficient. To solve this problem, in this paper, we propose a new hypergradient of LCBO leveraging the theory of nonsmooth implicit function theorem instead of using the restrive assumptions. In addition, we propose a *single-loop single-timescale* algorithm based on the double-momentum method and adaptive step size method and prove it can return a $(\delta, \epsilon)$-stationary point with $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(d_2^2\epsilon^{-4})$ iterations. Experiments on two applications demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Anselm Paulus, Georg Martius, Vit Musil

Embedding parameterized optimization problems as layers into machine learning architectures serves as a powerful inductive bias. Training such architectures with stochastic gradient descent requires care, as degenerate derivatives of the embedded optimization problem often render the gradients uninformative. We propose Lagrangian Proximal Gradient Descent (LPGD), a flexible framework for training architectures with embedded optimization layers that seamlessly integrates into automatic differentiation libraries. LPGD efficiently computes meaningful replacements of the degenerate optimization layer derivatives by re-running the forward solver oracle on a perturbed input. LPGD captures various previously proposed methods as special cases, while fostering deep links to traditional optimization methods. We theoretically analyze our method and demonstrate on historical and synthetic data that LPGD converges faster than gradient descent even in a differentiable setup.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Risheng Liu, Zhu Liu, Wei Yao, Shangzhi Zeng, Jin Zhang

This work focuses on addressing two major challenges in the context of large-scale nonconvex Bi-Level Optimization (BLO) problems, which are increasingly applied in machine learning due to their ability to model nested structures. These challenges involve ensuring computational efficiency and providing theoretical guarantees. While recent advances in scalable BLO algorithms have primarily relied on lower-level convexity simplification, our work specifically tackles large-scale BLO problems involving nonconvexity in both the upper and lower levels. We simultaneously address computational and theoretical challenges by introducing an innovative single-loop gradient-based algorithm, utilizing the Moreau envelope-based reformulation, and providing non-asymptotic convergence analysis for general nonconvex BLO problems. Notably, our algorithm relies solely on first-order gradient information, enhancing its practicality and efficiency, especially for large-scale BLO learning tasks. We validate our approach's effectiveness through experiments on various synthetic problems, two typical hyper-parameter learning tasks, and a real-world neural architecture search application, collectively demonstrating its superior performance.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Yu-Guan Hsieh, James Thornton, Eugene Ndiaye, Michal Klein, Marco Cuturi, Pierre Ablin

Beyond minimizing a single training loss, many deep learning estimation pipelines rely on an auxiliary objective to quantify and encourage desirable properties of the model (e.g. performance on another dataset, robustness, agreement with a prior). Although the simplest approach to incorporating an auxiliary loss is to sum it with the training loss as a regularizer, recent works have shown that one can improve performance by blending the gradients beyond a simple sum; this is known as *gradient surgery*. We cast the problem as a constrained minimization problem where the auxiliary objective is minimized among the set of minimizers of the training loss. To solve this bilevel problem, we follow a parameter update direction that combines the training loss gradient and the orthogonal projection of the auxiliary gradient to the training gradient. In a setting where gradients come from mini-batches, we explain how, using a moving average of the training loss gradients, we can carefully maintain this critical orthogonality property. We demonstrate that our method, Bloop, can lead to much better performances on NLP and vision experiments than other gradient surgery methods without EMA.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Riccardo Grazzi, Massimiliano Pontil, Saverio Salzo

We study the problem of efficiently computing the derivative of the fixed-point of a parametric nondifferentiable contraction map. This problem has wide applications in machine learning, including hyperparameter optimization, meta-learning and data poisoning attacks. We analyze two popular approaches: iterative differentiation (ITD) and approximate implicit differentiation (AID). A key challenge behind the nonsmooth setting is that the chain rule does not hold anymore. We build upon the work by Bolte et al. (2022), who prove linear convergence of nonsmooth ITD under a piecewise Lipschitz smooth assumption. In the deterministic case, we provide a linear rate for AID and an improved linear rate for ITD which closely match the ones for the smooth setting. We further introduce NSID, a new stochastic method to compute the implicit derivative when the contraction map is defined as the composition of an outer map and an inner map which is accessible only through a stochastic unbiased estimator. We establish rates for the convergence of NSID, encompassing the best available rates in the smooth setting. We also present illustrative experiments confirming our analysis.

Deep Learning

Charles Dickens, Changyu Gao, Connor Pryor, Stephen Wright, Lise Getoor

We leverage convex and bilevel optimization techniques to develop a general gradient-based parameter learning framework for neural-symbolic (NeSy) systems. We demonstrate our framework with NeuPSL, a state-of-the-art NeSy architecture. To achieve this, we propose a smooth primal and dual formulation of NeuPSL inference and show learning gradients are functions of the optimal dual variables. Additionally, we develop a dual block coordinate descent algorithm for the new formulation that naturally exploits warm-starts. This leads to over $100 \times$ learning runtime improvements over the current best NeuPSL inference method. Finally, we provide extensive empirical evaluations across $8$ datasets covering a range of tasks and demonstrate our learning framework achieves up to a $16$% point prediction performance improvement over alternative learning methods.

Optimization · Bilevel optimization

Ziqin Chen, Yongqiang Wang

Decentralized bilevel optimization based machine learning techniques are achieving remarkable success in a wide variety of domains. However, the intensive exchange of information (involving nested-loops of consensus or communication iterations) in existing decentralized bilevel optimization algorithms leads to a great challenge to ensure rigorous differential privacy, which, however, is necessary to bring the benefits of machine learning to domains where involved data are sensitive. By proposing a new decentralized stochastic bilevel-optimization algorithm which avoids nested-loops of information-exchange iterations, we achieve, for the first time, both differential privacy and accurate convergence in decentralized bilevel optimization. This is significant since even for single-level decentralized optimization and learning, existing differential-privacy solutions have to sacrifice convergence accuracy for privacy. Besides characterizing the convergence rate under nonconvex/convex/strongly convex conditions, we also rigorously quantify the price of differential privacy in the convergence rate. Experimental results on machine learning models confirm the efficacy of our algorithm.

Feihu Huang

Bilevel optimization is widely applied in many machine learning tasks such as hyper-parameter learning, meta learning and reinforcement learning. Although many algorithms recently have been developed to solve the bilevel optimization problems, they generally rely on the (strongly) convex lower-level problems. More recently, some methods have been proposed to solve the nonconvex-PL bilevel optimization problems, where their upper-level problems are possibly nonconvex, and their lower-level problems are also possibly nonconvex while satisfying Polyak-Łojasiewicz (PL) condition. However, these methods still have a high convergence complexity or a high computation complexity such as requiring compute expensive Hessian/Jacobian matrices and its inverses. In the paper, thus, we propose an efficient Hessian/Jacobian-free method (i.e., HJFBiO) with the optimal convergence complexity to solve the nonconvex-PL bilevel problems. Theoretically, under some mild conditions, we prove that our HJFBiO method obtains an optimal convergence rate of $O(\frac{1}{T})$, where $T$ denotes the number of iterations, and has an optimal gradient complexity of $O(\epsilon^{-1})$ in finding an $\epsilon$-stationary solution. We conduct some numerical experiments on the bilevel PL game and hyper-representation learning task to demonstrate efficiency of our proposed method.

Applications · Language, Speech and Dialog

Pingchuan Ma, Johnson Tsun-Hsuan Wang, Minghao Guo, Zhiqing Sun, Josh Tenenbaum, Daniela Rus, Chuang Gan, Wojciech Matusik

Large Language Models have recently gained significant attention in scientific discovery for their extensive knowledge and advanced reasoning capabilities. However, they encounter challenges in effectively simulating observational feedback and grounding it with language to propel advancements in physical scientific discovery. Conversely, human scientists undertake scientific discovery by formulating hypotheses, conducting experiments, and revising theories through observational analysis. Inspired by this, we propose to enhance the knowledge-driven, abstract reasoning abilities of LLMs with the computational strength of simulations. We introduce Scientific Generative Agent (SGA), a bilevel optimization framework: LLMs act as knowledgeable and versatile thinkers, proposing scientific hypotheses and reason about discrete components, such as physics equations or molecule structures; meanwhile, simulations function as experimental platforms, providing observational feedback and optimizing via differentiability for continuous parts, such as physical parameters. We conduct extensive experiments to demonstrate our framework's efficacy in constitutive law discovery and molecular design, unveiling novel solutions that differ from conventional human expectations yet remain coherent upon analysis.