论文检索

Deep Learning · Graph Neural Networks

Yue Hou, He Zhu, Ruomei Liu, Yingke Su, Junran Wu, Ke Xu

Distributional discrepancy between training and test data can lead models to make inaccurate predictions when encountering out-of-distribution (OOD) samples in real-world applications. Although existing graph OOD detection methods leverage data-centric techniques to extract effective representations, their performance remains compromised by structural redundancy that induces semantic shifts. To address this dilemma, we propose RedOUT, an unsupervised framework that integrates structural entropy into test-time OOD detection for graph classification. Concretely, we introduce the Redundancy-aware Graph Information Bottleneck (ReGIB) and decompose the objective into essential information and irrelevant redundancy. By minimizing structural entropy, the decoupled redundancy is reduced, and theoretically grounded upper and lower bounds are proposed for optimization. Extensive experiments on real-world datasets demonstrate the superior performance of RedOUT on OOD detection. Specifically, our method achieves an average improvement of 6.7\%, significantly surpassing the best competitor by 17.3\% on the ClinTox/LIPO dataset pair.

Probabilistic Methods · Bayesian Models and Methods

Linye Li, Yufei Chen, Xiaodong Yue

Uncertainty estimation is crucial for ensuring the reliability of machine learning models in safety-critical applications. Evidential Deep Learning (EDL) offers a principled framework by modeling predictive uncertainty through Dirichlet distributions over class probabilities. However, existing EDL methods predominantly rely on level-0 hard labels, which supervised a uncertainty-aware model with full certainty. We argue that hard labels not only fail to capture epistemic uncertainty but also obscure the aleatoric uncertainty arising from inherent data noise and label ambiguity. As a result, EDL models often produce degenerate Dirichlet distributions that collapse to near-deterministic outputs. To overcome these limitations, we propose a vicinal risk minimization paradigm for EDL by incorporating level-1 supervision in the form of vicinally smoothed conditional label distributions. This richer supervision exposes the model to local label uncertainty, enhancing aleatoric uncertainty quantification, while also mitigating the degeneration of the Dirichlet distribution into a Dirac delta function, thereby improving epistemic uncertainty modeling. Extensive experiments show that our approach consistently outperforms standard EDL baselines across synthetic datasets, covariate-shifted out-of-distribution generalization tasks, and out-of-distribution detection benchmarks, providing more reliable uncertainty estimates.

Probabilistic Methods · Bayesian Models and Methods

Steven An

Programmatic Weak Supervision (PWS) aims to reduce the cost of constructing large high quality labeled datasets often used in training modern machine learning models. A major component of the PWS pipeline is the label model, which amalgamates predictions from multiple noisy weak supervision sources, i.e. labeling functions (LFs), to label datapoints. While most label models are either probabilistic or adversarial, a recently proposed label model achieves strong empirical performance without falling into either camp. That label model constructs a polytope of plausible labelings using the LF predictions and outputs the "center" of that polytope as its proposed labeling. In this paper, we attempt to theoretically study that strategy by proposing Bayesian Balsubramani-Freund (BBF), a label model that implicitly constructs a polytope of plausible labelings and selects a labeling in its interior. We show an assortment of statistical results for BBF: log-concavity of its posterior, its form of solution, consistency, and rates of convergence. Extensive experiments compare our proposed method against twelve baseline label models over eleven datasets. BBF compares favorably to other Bayesian label models and label models that don't use datapoint features -- matching or exceeding their performance on eight out of eleven datasets.

Mudit Gaur, Utsav Singh, Amrit Singh Bedi, Raghu Pasupathy, Vaneet Aggarwal

Bilevel reinforcement learning (BRL) has emerged as a powerful framework for aligning generative models, yet its theoretical foundations, especially sample complexity bounds, remain underexplored. In this work, we present the first sample complexity bound for BRL, establishing a rate of $\mathcal{O}(\epsilon^{-3})$ in continuous state-action spaces. Traditional MDP analysis techniques do not extend to BRL due to its nested structure and non-convex lower-level problems. We overcome these challenges by leveraging the Polyak-Łojasiewicz (PL) condition and the MDP structure to obtain closed-form gradients, enabling tight sample complexity analysis. Our analysis also extends to general bi-level optimization settings with non-convex lower levels, where we achieve state-of-the-art sample complexity results of $\mathcal{O}(\epsilon^{-3})$ improving upon existing bounds of $\mathcal{O}(\epsilon^{-6})$. Additionally, we address the computational bottleneck of hypergradient estimation by proposing a fully first-order, Hessian-free algorithm suitable for large-scale problems.

Theory · Learning Theory

Yuxin Ma, Dmitriy Kunisky

We introduce a new family of algorithms for detecting and estimating a rank-one signal from a noisy observation under prior information about that signal's direction, focusing on examples where the signal is known to have entries biased to be positive. Given a matrix observation $\mathbf{Y}$, our algorithms construct a *nonlinear Laplacian*, another matrix of the form $\mathbf{Y} + \mathrm{diag}(\sigma(\mathbf{Y1}))$ for a nonlinear $\sigma: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R}$, and examine the top eigenvalue and eigenvector of this matrix. When $\mathbf{Y}$ is the (suitably normalized) adjacency matrix of a graph, our approach gives a class of algorithms that search for unusually dense subgraphs by computing a spectrum of the graph "deformed" by the degree profile $\mathbf{Y1}$. We study the performance of such algorithms compared to direct spectral algorithms (the case $\sigma = 0$) on models of sparse principal component analysis with biased signals, including the Gaussian planted submatrix problem. For such models, we rigorously characterize the strength of rank-one signal, as a function of the nonlinearity $\sigma$, required for an outlier eigenvalue to appear in the spectrum of a nonlinear Laplacian matrix. While identifying the $\sigma$ that minimizes the required signal strength in closed form seems intractable, we explore three approaches to design $\sigma$ numerically: exhaustively searching over simple classes of $\sigma$, learning $\sigma$ from datasets of problem instances, and tuning $\sigma$ using black-box optimization of the critical signal strength. We find both theoretically and empirically that, if $\sigma$ is chosen appropriately, then nonlinear Laplacian spectral algorithms substantially outperform direct spectral algorithms, while retaining the conceptual simplicity of spectral methods compared to broader classes of computations like approximate message passing or general first order methods.

Computer Vision · 3D Rendering & Reconstruction

Ziang Cao, Zhaoxi Chen, Liang Pan, Ziwei Liu

3D modeling is moving from virtual to physical. Existing 3D generation primarily emphasizes geometries and textures while neglecting physical-grounded modeling. Consequently, despite the rapid development of 3D generative models, the synthesized 3D assets often overlook rich and important physical properties, hampering their real-world application in physical domains like simulation and embodied AI. As an initial attempt to address this challenge, we propose \textbf{PhysX}, an end-to-end paradigm for physical-grounded 3D asset generation. \textbf{1)} To bridge the critical gap in physics-annotated 3D datasets, we present \textbf{\ourname}\ - the first physics-grounded 3D dataset systematically annotated across five foundational dimensions: \textbf{\textcolor{color2}{absolute scale}}, \textbf{\textcolor{color3}{material}}, \textbf{\textcolor{color1}{affordance}}, \textbf{\textcolor{color4}{kinematics}}, and \textbf{\textcolor{color5}{function description}}. In particular, we devise a scalable human-in-the-loop annotation pipeline based on vision-language models, which enables efficient creation of physics-first assets from raw 3D assets. \textbf{2)} Furthermore, we propose \textbf{PhysXGen}, a feed-forward framework for physics-grounded 3D asset generation, injecting physical knowledge into the pre-trained 3D structural space. Specifically, PhysXGen employs a dual-branch architecture to explicitly model the latent correlations between 3D structures and physical properties, thereby producing 3D assets with plausible physical predictions while preserving the native geometry quality. Extensive experiments validate the superior performance and promising generalization capability of our framework. All the code, data, and models will be released to facilitate future research in generative physical AI.

Social Aspects · Privacy-preserving Statistics and Machine Learning

Binqian Xu, Haiyang Mei, Zechen Bai, Jinjin Gong, Rui Yan, Guosen Xie, Yazhou Yao, Basura Fernando, Xiangbo Shu

Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) with Federated Learning (FL) can quickly adapt to privacy-sensitive tasks, but face significant challenges such as high communication costs and increased attack risks, due to their reliance on multi-round communication. To address this, One-shot FL (OFL) has emerged, aiming to complete adaptation in a single client-server communication. However, existing adaptive ensemble OFL methods still need more than one round of communication, because correcting heterogeneity-induced local bias relies on aggregated global supervision, meaning they still do not achieve true one-shot communication. In this work, we make the first attempt to achieve true one-shot communication for MLLMs under OFL, by investigating whether implicit (i.e., initial rather than aggregated) global supervision alone can effectively correct local training bias. Our key finding from the empirical study is that imposing directional supervision on local training substantially mitigates client conflicts and local bias. Building on this insight, we propose YOCO, in which directional supervision with sign-regularized LoRA B enforces global consistency, while sparsely regularized LoRA A preserves client-specific adaptability. Experiments demonstrate that YOCO cuts communication to $\sim$0.03\% of multi-round FL while surpassing those methods in several multimodal scenarios and consistently outperforming all one-shot competitors.

Optimization · Everything Else

Laetitia Chapel, Romain Tavenard, Samuel Vaiter

Optimal Transport (OT) has attracted significant interest in the machine learning community, not only for its ability to define meaningful distances between probability distributions -- such as the Wasserstein distance -- but also for its formulation of OT plans. Its computational complexity remains a bottleneck, though, and slicing techniques have been developed to scale OT to large datasets. Recently, a novel slicing scheme, dubbed min-SWGG, lifts a single one-dimensional plan back to the original multidimensional space, finally selecting the slice that yields the lowest Wasserstein distance as an approximation of the full OT plan. Despite its computational and theoretical advantages, min-SWGG inherits typical limitations of slicing methods: (i) the number of required slices grows exponentially with the data dimension, and (ii) it is constrained to linear projections. Here, we reformulate min-SWGG as a bilevel optimization problem and propose a differentiable approximation scheme to efficiently identify the optimal slice, even in high-dimensional settings. We furthermore define its generalized extension for accommodating data living on manifolds. Finally, we demonstrate the practical value of our approach in various applications, including gradient flows on manifolds and high-dimensional spaces, as well as a novel sliced OT-based conditional flow matching for image generation -- where fast computation of transport plans is essential.

Social Aspects · Privacy-preserving Statistics and Machine Learning

Yingyu Lin, Erchi Wang, Yian Ma, Yu-Xiang Wang

We propose a framework to convert $(\varepsilon, \delta)$-approximate Differential Privacy (DP) mechanisms into $(\varepsilon', 0)$-pure DP mechanisms under certain conditions, a process we call ``purification.'' This algorithmic technique leverages randomized post-processing with calibrated noise to eliminate the $\delta$ parameter while achieving near-optimal privacy-utility tradeoff for pure DP. It enables a new design strategy for pure DP algorithms: first run an approximate DP algorithm with certain conditions, and then purify. This approach allows one to leverage techniques such as strong composition and propose-test-release that require $\delta>0$ in designing pure-DP methods with $\delta=0$. We apply this framework in various settings, including Differentially Private Empirical Risk Minimization (DP-ERM), stability-based release, and query release tasks. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work with a statistically and computationally efficient reduction from approximate DP to pure DP. Finally, we illustrate the use of this reduction for proving lower bounds under approximate DP constraints with explicit dependence in $\delta$, avoiding the sophisticated fingerprinting code construction.

Applications · Neuroscience, Cognitive Science

Wenjie Wei, Malu Zhang, Jieyuan (Eric) Zhang, Ammar Belatreche, Shuai Wang, Yimeng Shan, Hanwen Liu, Honglin Cao, Guoqing Wang, Yang Yang 等

Spiking Neural Networks (SNNs) offer an energy-efficient paradigm for machine intelligence, but their continued scaling poses challenges for resource-limited deployment. Despite recent advances in binary SNNs, the storage and computational demands remain substantial for large-scale networks. To further explore the compression and acceleration potential of SNNs, we propose Sub-bit Spiking Neural Networks (S$^2$NNs) that represent weights with less than one bit. Specifically, we first establish an S$^2$NN baseline by leveraging the clustering patterns of kernels in well-trained binary SNNs. This baseline is highly efficient but suffers from \textit{outlier-induced codeword selection bias} during training. To mitigate this issue, we propose an \textit{outlier-aware sub-bit weight quantization} (OS-Quant) method, which optimizes codeword selection by identifying and adaptively scaling outliers. Furthermore, we propose a \textit{membrane potential-based feature distillation} (MPFD) method, improving the performance of highly compressed S$^2$NN via more precise guidance from a teacher model. Extensive results on vision reveal that S$^2$NN outperforms existing quantized SNNs in both performance and efficiency, making it promising for edge computing applications.

Computer Vision · Image and Video Generation

Yuyang Hu, Kangfu Mei, Mojtaba Ardakani, Ulugbek Kamilov, Peyman Milanfar, Mauricio Delbracio

Diffusion models show promise for image restoration, but existing methods often struggle with inconsistent fidelity and undesirable artifacts. To address this, we introduce Kernel Density Steering (KDS), a novel inference-time framework promoting robust, high-fidelity outputs through explicit local mode-seeking. KDS employs an $N$-particle ensemble of diffusion samples, computing patch-wise kernel density estimation gradients from their collective outputs. These gradients steer patches in each particle towards shared, higher-density regions identified within the ensemble. This collective local mode-seeking mechanism, acting as "collective wisdom", steers samples away from spurious modes prone to artifacts, arising from independent sampling or model imperfections, and towards more robust, high-fidelity structures. This allows us to obtain better quality samples at the expense of higher compute by simultaneously sampling multiple particles. As a plug-and-play framework, KDS requires no retraining or external verifiers, seamlessly integrating with various diffusion samplers. Extensive numerical validations demonstrate KDS substantially improves both quantitative and qualitative performance on challenging real-world super-resolution and image inpainting tasks.

General Machine Learning · Representation Learning

Man Ho Lam, Chaozheng Wang, Jen-Tse Huang, Michael R Lyu

Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated strong capabilities in code-related tasks, but their robustness in code reasoning under perturbations remains underexplored. We introduce CodeCrash, a stress-testing framework with 1,279 questions from CRUXEVAL and LIVECODEBENCH, designed to evaluate reasoning reliability under structural perturbations and misleading natural language (NL) contexts. Through a systematic evaluation of 17 LLMs, we find that models often shortcut reasoning by over-relying on NL cues, leading to an average performance degradation of 23.2% in output prediction tasks. Even with Chain-of-Thought reasoning, models on average still have a 13.8% drop due to distractibility and rationalization, revealing a lack of critical reasoning capability to distinguish the actual code behaviors. While Large Reasoning Models with internal reasoning mechanisms improve robustness by fostering critical thinking, plausible yet incorrect hints can trigger pathological self-reflection, causing 2-3 times token consumption and even catastrophic cognitive dissonance in extreme cases for QwQ-32B. We refer to this phenomenon as Reasoning Collapse. CodeCrash provides a rigorous benchmark for evaluating robustness in code reasoning, guiding future research and development toward more reliable and resilient models.

Computer Vision · 3D Rendering & Reconstruction

Yuchen Lin, Chenguo Lin, Panwang Pan, Honglei Yan, Feng Yiqiang, Yadong Mu, Katerina Fragkiadaki

We introduce PartCrafter, the first structured 3D generative model that jointly synthesizes multiple semantically meaningful and geometrically distinct 3D meshes from a single RGB image. Unlike existing methods that either produce monolithic 3D shapes or follow two-stage pipelines, i.e. first segmenting an image and then reconstructing each segment, PartCrafter adopts a unified, compositional generation architecture that does not rely on pre-segmented inputs. Conditioned on a single image, it simultaneously denoises multiple 3D parts, enabling end-to-end part-aware generation of both individual objects and complex multi-object scenes. PartCrafter builds upon a pretrained 3D mesh diffusion transformer (DiT) trained on whole objects, inheriting the pretrained weights, encoder, and decoder, and introduces two key innovations: (1) A compositional latent space, where each 3D part is represented by a set of disentangled latent tokens; (2) A hierarchical attention mechanism that enables structured information flow both within individual parts and across all parts, ensuring global coherence while preserving part-level detail during generation. To support part-level supervision, we curate a new dataset by mining part-level annotations from large-scale 3D object datasets. Experiments show that PartCrafter outperforms existing approaches in generating decomposable 3D meshes, including parts that are not directly visible in input images, demonstrating the strength of part-aware generative priors for 3D understanding and synthesis. Code and training data are released.

Social Aspects · Everything Else

Yuzhe YANG, Yifei Zhang, Minghao Wu, Kaidi Zhang, Yunmiao Zhang, Honghai Yu, Yan Hu, Benyou Wang

The study of social emergence has long been a central focus in social science. Traditional modeling approaches, such as rule-based Agent-Based Models (ABMs), struggle to capture the diversity and complexity of human behavior, particularly the irrational factors emphasized in behavioral economics. Recently, large language model (LLM) agents have gained traction as simulation tools for modeling human behavior in social science and role-playing applications. Studies suggest that LLMs can account for cognitive biases, emotional fluctuations, and other non-rational influences, enabling more realistic simulations of socio-economic dynamics. In this work, we introduce TwinMarket, a novel multi-agent framework that leverages LLMs to simulate socio-economic systems. Specifically, we examine how individual behaviors, through interactions and feedback mechanisms, give rise to collective dynamics and emergent phenomena. Through experiments in a simulated stock market environment, we demonstrate how individual actions can trigger group behaviors, leading to emergent outcomes such as financial bubbles and recessions. Our approach provides valuable insights into the complex interplay between individual decision-making and collective socio-economic patterns.

Computer Vision · Vision Models & Multimodal

Zhongwei Wan, Zhihao Dou, Che Liu, Yu Zhang, Dongfei Cui, Qinjian Zhao, Hui Shen, Jing Xiong, Yi Xin, Yifan Jiang 等

Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown promising capabilities in reasoning tasks, yet still struggle significantly with complex problems requiring explicit self-reflection and self-correction, especially compared to their unimodal text-based counterparts. Existing reflection methods are simplistic and struggle to generate meaningful, instructive feedback, as the reasoning ability and knowledge limits of pre-trained models are largely fixed during initial training. To overcome these challenges, we propose \textit{multimodal \textbf{S}elf-\textbf{R}eflection enhanced reasoning with Group Relative \textbf{P}olicy \textbf{O}ptimization} \textbf{SRPO}, a two-stage reflection-aware reinforcement learning (RL) framework explicitly designed to enhance multimodal LLM reasoning. In the first stage, we construct a high-quality, reflection-focused dataset under the guidance of an advanced MLLM, which generates reflections based on initial responses to help the policy model to learn both reasoning and self-reflection. In the second stage, we introduce a novel reward mechanism within the GRPO framework that encourages concise and cognitively meaningful reflection while avoiding redundancy. Extensive experiments across multiple multimodal reasoning benchmarks—including MathVista, MathVision, Mathverse, and MMMU-Pro—using Qwen-2.5-VL-7B and Qwen-2.5-VL-32B demonstrate that SRPO significantly outperforms state-of-the-art models, achieving notable improvements in both reasoning accuracy and reflection quality.

Enjun Du, Xunkai Li, Tian Jin, Zhihan Zhang, Rong-Hua Li, Guoren Wang

The era of foundation models has revolutionized AI research, yet Graph Foundation Models (GFMs) remain constrained by the scarcity of large-scale graph corpora. Traditional graph data synthesis techniques primarily focus on simplistic structural operations, lacking the capacity to generate semantically rich nodes with meaningful textual attributes—a critical limitation for real-world applications. While large language models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional text generation capabilities, their direct application to graph synthesis is impeded by context window limitations, hallucination phenomena, and structural consistency challenges. To address these issues, we introduce \textbf{GraphMaster}—the first multi-agent framework specifically designed for graph data synthesis in data-limited environments. GraphMaster orchestrates four specialized LLM agents (Manager, Perception, Enhancement, and Evaluation) that collaboratively optimize the synthesis process through iterative refinement, ensuring both semantic coherence and structural integrity. To rigorously evaluate our approach, we create new data-limited “Sub” variants of six standard graph benchmarks, specifically designed to test synthesis capabilities under realistic constraints. Additionally, we develop a novel interpretability assessment framework that combines human evaluation with a principled Grassmannian manifold-based analysis, providing both qualitative and quantitative measures of semantic coherence. Experimental results demonstrate that GraphMaster significantly outperforms traditional synthesis methods across multiple datasets, establishing a strong foundation for advancing GFMs in data-scarce environments.

Reinforcement Learning · Deep RL

Wenlin Zhang, Xiangyang Li, Kuicai Dong, Yichao Wang, Pengyue Jia, Xiaopeng Li, Yingyi Zhang, Derong Xu, Zhaocheng Du, Huifeng Guo 等

Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) enhances large language models (LLMs) by integrating external knowledge, yet traditional RAG systems struggle with static workflows and limited adaptability for complex, multistep reasoning tasks. Agentic RAG systems, such as DeepResearch, address these issues through dynamic retrieval, iterative context refinement, and adaptive workflows. However, recent methods like Search-R1, which rely on outcome-based reinforcement learning, face challenges such as low exploration efficiency, gradient conflict, and sparse reward signals. To tackle these limitations, we introduce ReasonRAG, a novel method that leverages RAG-ProGUIDE—a high-quality dataset providing fine-grained, process-level rewards for query generation, evidence extraction, and answer generation. By employing process-supervised reinforcement learning, ReasonRAG enhances LLMs’ autonomous capabilities in search, query generation, evidence extraction, and answer synthesis. Experimental results show that ReasonRAG, utilizing RAG-ProGUIDE, outperforms existing approaches like Search-R1 and traditional RAG systems, achieving superior performance on five benchmark datasets with only 5k training instances—significantly fewer than the 90k required by Search-R1. Our code is available at https://github.com/Applied-Machine-Learning-Lab/ReasonRAG.

Deep Learning · Attention Mechanisms

Xiangyu Hong, Che Jiang, Kai Tian, Biqing Qi, Youbang Sun, Ning Ding, Bowen Zhou

Attributing the behavior of Transformer models to internal computations is a central challenge in mechanistic interpretability. We introduce DePass, a unified framework for feature attribution based on a single decomposed forward pass. DePass decomposes hidden states into customized additive components, then propagates them with attention scores and MLP's activations fixed. It achieves faithful, fine-grained attribution without requiring auxiliary training. We validate DePass across token-level, model component-level, and subspace-level attribution tasks, demonstrating its effectiveness and fidelity. Our experiments highlight its potential to attribute information flow between arbitrary components of a Transformer model. We hope DePass serves as a foundational tool for broader applications in interpretability.

Applications

yuyang Hong, Jiaqi Gu, Yang Qi, Lubin Fan, Yue Wu, Ying Wang, Kun Ding, SHIMING XIANG, Jieping Ye

The task of Knowlegde-Based Visual Question Answering (KB-VQA) requires the model to understand visual features and retrieve external knowledge. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) have been employed to address this problem through knowledge base querying. However, existing work demonstrate two limitations: insufficient interactivity during knowledge retrieval and ineffective organization of retrieved information for Visual-Language Model (VLM). To address these challenges, we propose a three-stage visual language model with Process, Retrieve and Filter (VLM-PRF) framework. For interactive retrieval, VLM-PRF uses reinforcement learning (RL) to guide the model to strategically process information via tool-driven operations. For knowledge filtering, our method trains the VLM to transform the raw retrieved information into into task-specific knowledge. With a dual reward as supervisory signals, VLM-PRF successfully enable model to optimize retrieval strategies and answer generation capabilities simultaneously. Experiments on two datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework.

Data-centric AI · Everything Else

Ruoxi Jia, Luis Oala, Wenjie Xiong, Suqin Ge, Jiachen (Tianhao) Wang, Feiyang Kang, Dawn Song

We argue that the machine learning value chain is structurally unsustainable due to an economic data processing inequality: each state in the data cycle from inputs to model weights to synthetic outputs refines technical signal but strips economic equity from data generators. We show, by analyzing seventy-three public data deals, that the majority of value accrues to aggregators, with documented creator royalties rounding to zero and widespread opacity of deal terms. This is not just an economic welfare concern: as data and its derivatives become economic assets, the feedback loop that sustains current learning algorithms is at risk. We identify three structural faults - missing provenance, asymmetric bargaining power, and non-dynamic pricing - as the operational machinery of this inequality. In our analysis, we trace these problems along the machine learning value chain and propose an Equitable Data-Value Exchange (EDVEX) Framework to enable a minimal market that benefits all participants. Finally, we outline research directions where our community can make concrete contributions to data deals and contextualize our position with related and orthogonal viewpoints.