论文检索

输入标题、作者或关键词,从 12,113 篇学术成果中精准定位

会议来源 已选 1 项

机器学习与综合 AI

自然语言处理

计算机视觉

数据挖掘与 Web

多媒体与图形学

已选择 1 个会议
支持跨会议组合检索,PDF 均跳转至官方来源
已筛选 ICLR
12,113篇论文
第 203 / 606 页

General Machine Learning · Transfer, Multitask and Meta-learning

Qinyuan Ye, Robin Jia, Xiang Ren

Large language models demonstrate the intriguing ability to perform unseen tasks via in-context learning. However, it remains unclear what mechanisms inside the model drive such task-level generalization. In this work, we approach this question through the lens of off-by-one addition (i.e., 1+1=3, 2+2=5, 3+3=?), a two-step, counterfactual task with an unexpected +1 function as a second step. Leveraging circuit-style interpretability techniques such as path patching, we analyze the models' internal computations behind their performance and present three key findings. First, we identify a mechanism that explains the model's generalization from standard addition to off-by-one addition. It resembles the induction head mechanism described in prior work, yet operates at a higher level of abstraction; we therefore term it "function induction" in this work. Second, we show that the induction of the +1 function is governed by multiple attention heads in parallel, each of which emits a distinct piece of the +1 function. Finally, we find that this function induction mechanism is reused in a broader range of tasks, including synthetic tasks such as shifted multiple-choice QA and algorithmic tasks such as base-8 addition. Overall, our findings offer deeper insights into how reusable and composable structures within language models enable task-level generalization.

General Machine Learning · Causality

Dezhi Yang, Qiaoyu Tan, Carlotta Domeniconi, Jun Wang, Lizhen Cui, Guoxian Yu

Learning the dynamic causal structure is a difficult challenge in discovering causality from time series. Most existing studies rely on distributional or structural invariance to uncover the underlying causal dynamics, assuming stationary or partially stationary causality, which frequently conflicts with complex causal relationships in the real world. This boosts temporal causal discovery to encompass fully dynamic causality, where both instantaneous and lagged causal dependencies may change over time, bringing significant challenges to the efficiency and stability of causal discovery. To tackle these challenges, we introduce DyCausal, a dynamic causal structure learning framework that leverages convolutional networks to effectively model causal structures within coarse-grained time windows, and introduces linear interpolation to refine causal structures to each time step and recover time-varying causal graphs. In addition, we propose an acyclic constraint based on matrix norm scaling. It is more stable both theoretically and empirically, and constrains loops in dynamic causal structures with improved efficiency. Evaluations on both synthetic and real-world datasets prove that DyCausal significantly outperforms existing methods and identifies fully dynamic causal structures from coarse to fine.

General Machine Learning · Everything Else

Wenxing Zhou, Timothy Cannings

We introduce a new, flexible, and theoretically justified framework for dimension reduction in high-dimensional regression, based on an ensemble of random projections. Specifically, we consider disjoint groups of independent random projections, retain the best projection in each group according to the empirical regression performance on the projected covariates, and then aggregate the selected projections via singular value decomposition. The singular values quantify the relative importance of corresponding projection directions and guide the dimension selection process. We investigate various aspects of our framework, including the choice of projection distribution and the number of projections used. Our theoretical results show that the expected estimation error decreases as the number of groups of projections increases. Finally, we demonstrate that our proposal consistently matches or outperforms state-of-the-art methods through extensive numerical studies on simulated and real data.

Applications · Everything Else

Md Ahsanul Haque, Ismail Hossain, Mahmuduzzaman Kamol, Jahangir Alam, Suresh Kumar Amalapuram, Sajedul Talukder, Mohammad Saidur Rahman

Machine learning (ML)-based malware detection systems often fail to account for the dynamic nature of real-world training and test data distributions. In practice, these distributions evolve due to frequent changes in the Android ecosystem, adversarial development of new malware families, and the continuous emergence of both benign and malicious applications. Prior studies have shown that such concept drift—distributional shifts in benign and malicious samples, leads to significant degradation in detection performance over time. Despite the practical importance of this issue, existing datasets are often outdated and limited in temporal scope, diversity of malware families, and sample scale, making them insufficient for the systematic evaluation of concept drift in malware detection. To address this gap, we present LAMDA, the largest and most temporally diverse Android malware benchmark to date, designed specifically for concept drift analysis. LAMDA spans 12 years (2013–2025, excluding 2015), includes over 1 million samples (approximately 37\% labeled as malware), and covers 1,380 malware families and 150,000 singleton samples, reflecting the natural distribution and evolution of real-world Android applications. We empirically demonstrate LAMDA's utility by quantifying the performance degradation of standard ML models over time and analyzing feature stability across years. As the most comprehensive Android malware dataset to date, LAMDA enables in-depth research into temporal drift, generalization, explainability, and evolving detection challenges.

Reinforcement Learning · Multi-agent

Chengzhi Liu, Yuzhe YANG, Kaiwen Zhou, Zhen Zhang, Yue Fan, Yanan Xie, Peng Qi, Xin Wang

The promotion of academic papers has become an important means of enhancing research visibility. where the appeal of dissemination largely determines its effectiveness. However, existing automated methods struggle limited storytelling, insufficient aesthetic quality, and constrained self-adjustment, making it difficult to achieve efficient and engaging dissemination. At the heart of those challenges is a simple principle: *there is no way to improve it when you cannot evaluate it right*. To address this, we introduce **EvoPresent**, a self-improvement agent framework that unifies coherent narratives, aesthetic-aware designs, and realistic presentation delivery via virtual characters. Central to EvoPresent is **PresAesth**, a multi-task reinforcement learning (RL) aesthetic model that provides reliable aesthetic scoring, defect adjustment, and comparative feedback, enabling iterative self-improvement even under limited aesthetic training data. To systematically evaluate the methods, we introduce **EvoPresent Benchmark**, a comprehensive benchmark comprising: *Presentation Generation Quality*, built on 650 top-tier AI conference papers with multimodal resources (slides, videos and scripts) to assess both content and design; and *Aesthetic Awareness*, consisting of 2,000 slide pairs with varying aesthetic levels, supporting joint training and evaluation on scoring, defect adjustment, and comparison. Our findings highlight that (i) High-quality feedback is essential for agent self-improvement, while initial capability alone does not guarantee effective self-correction. (ii) Automated generation pipelines exhibit a trade-off between visual design and content construction. (iii) Multi-task RL training shows stronger generalization in aesthetic awareness tasks.

Applications · Neuroscience, Cognitive Science

Lulu Gong, Shreya Saxena

Linear dynamical systems (LDSs) have been powerful tools for modeling high-dimensional time-series data across many domains, including neuroscience. However, a single LDS often struggles to capture the heterogeneity of neural data, where trajectories recorded under different conditions can have variations in their dynamics. Mixtures of linear dynamical systems (MoLDS) provide a path to model these variations in temporal dynamics for different observed trajectories. However, MoLDS remains difficult to apply in complex and noisy settings, limiting its practical use in neural data analysis. Tensor-based moment methods can provide global identifiability guarantees for MoLDS, but their practical performance degrades in high-noise or complex scenarios. Commonly used expectation-maximization (EM) methods offer flexibility in fitting latent models but are highly sensitive to initialization and prone to poor local minima. Here, we propose a tensor-based moment method that provides identifiability guarantees for learning MoLDS, which can be followed by EM updates to combine the strengths of both approaches. The novelty in our approach lies in the construction of moment tensors using the input-output data, on which we then apply Simultaneous Matrix Diagonalization (SMD) to recover globally consistent estimates of mixture weights and system parameters. These estimates can then be refined through a full Kalman EM algorithm, with closed-form updates for all LDS parameters. We validate our framework on synthetic benchmarks and real-world datasets. On synthetic data, the proposed Tensor-EM method achieves more reliable recovery and improved robustness compared to either pure tensor or randomly initialized EM methods. We then apply this method to two neural datasets from non-human primates doing reaching tasks. For both datasets, our method successfully models and clusters different conditions as separate subsystems. These results demonstrate that MoLDS provides an effective framework for modeling complex neural data in different brain regions, and that Tensor-EM is a principled and reliable approach to MoLDS learning for these applications.

Reinforcement Learning · Multi-agent

Ruida WANG, Jiarui Yao, Rui Pan, Shizhe Diao, Tong Zhang

Solving math problems through verifiable languages such as Lean has significantly impacted both the mathematics and computer science communities. Current state-of-the-art models are often trained with expensive online Reinforcement Learning (RL) or expert iteration. However, these approaches rely on fixed problem sets, which causes inefficient training and limits the model to tackle complex problems. To overcome these limitations, we propose **GAR**: *Generative Adversarial Reinforcement learning*, a comprehensive RL training framework that jointly trains the problem composer and solver in an adversarial loop. **GAR** introduces an implicit curriculum learning mechanism, which aligns task difficulty with the prover's evolving capability. It thereby improves the training efficiency and enables stronger performance of proving advanced theorems. Experiments show that with **GAR** training, Goedel-Prover-V2-8B and DeepSeek-Prover-V2-7B achieve an average relative improvement in pass@32 of **4.20%** on MiniF2F-Test benchmark, while DeepSeek-Prover-V2's pass@32 on ProofNet-Test increases from 22.58% to **25.81%**. Beyond formal proving, **GAR** establishes a general RL paradigm for co-evolution of problem generation and solving under verifiable environments. The training code for this paper is open-sourced in [https://github.com/RickySkywalker/GAR-Official](https://github.com/RickySkywalker/GAR-Official)

General Machine Learning · Transfer, Multitask and Meta-learning

Dongkyu Cho, Taesup Moon, Rumi Chunara, Kyunghyun Cho, Sungmin Cha

Continual learning (CL) has traditionally focused on minimizing exemplar memory, a constraint often misaligned with modern systems where GPU time, not storage, is the primary bottleneck. This paper challenges this paradigm by investigating a more realistic regime: one where memory is abundant enough to mitigate forgetting, but full retraining from scratch remains prohibitively expensive. In this practical "middle ground", we find that the core challenge shifts from stability to plasticity, as models become biased toward prior tasks and struggle to learn new ones. Conversely, improved stability allows simple replay baselines to outperform the state-of-the-art methods at a fraction of the GPU cost. To address this newly surfaced trade-off, we propose Weight Space Consolidation, a lightweight method that combines (1) rank-based parameter resets to restore plasticity with (2) weight averaging to enhance stability. Validated on both class-incremental learning with image classifiers and continual instruction tuning with large language models, our approach outperforms strong baselines while matching the low computational cost of replay, offering a scalable alternative to expensive full-retraining. These findings challenge long-standing CL assumptions and establish a new, cost-efficient baseline for real-world CL systems where exemplar memory is no longer the limiting factor.

Zhaoyang Liu, JingJing Xie, Zichen Ding, Zehao Li, Bowen Yang, Zhenyu Wu, Xuehui Wang, Qiushi Sun, Shi Liu, Weiyun Wang 等

Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have enabled computer use agents (CUAs) that operate GUIs autonomously, showing great potential, yet progress is limited by the lack of large-scale, open-source computer use data and foundation models. In this work, we introduce ScaleCUA, a step toward scaling open-source CUAs. It offers a large-scale dataset spanning 6 operating systems and 3 task domains, built via a closed-loop pipeline uniting automated agents with human experts. Trained on this scaled-up data, ScaleCUA can operate seamlessly across platforms. Specifically, it delivers strong gains over baselines (+26.6 on WebArena-Lite-v2, +10.7 on ScreenSpot-Pro) and sets new state-of-the-art results (94.4% on MMBench-GUI L1-Hard, 60.6% on OSWorld-G, 47.4% on WebArena-Lite-v2). These findings underscore the power of data-driven scaling for general-purpose computer use agents. We will release data, models, and code to advance future research.

Theory · Game Theory

Linjian Meng, Youzhi Zhang, Shangdong Yang, Wenbin Li, Tianyu Ding, Yang Gao

Regret Matching (RM) and its variants are widely employed to learn a Nash equilibrium (NE) in large-scale games. However, most existing research only establishes a theoretical convergence rate of $O(1/\sqrt{T})$ for these algorithms in learning an NE. Recent studies have shown that smooth RM$^+$ variants, the advanced variants of RM, can achieve an improved convergence rate of $O(1/T)$. Despite this improvement, smooth RM$^+$ variants lose the parameter-free property, i.e., no parameters that need to be tuned, a highly desirable feature in practical applications. In this paper, we propose a novel smooth RM$^+$ variant called Monotone Increasing Smooth Predictive Regret Matching$^+$ (MI-SPRM$^+$), which retains the parameter-free property while still achieving a theoretical convergence rate of $O(1/T)$. To achieve these properties, MI-SPRM$^+$ employs a technology called Adaptive Regret Domain (ARD), which ensures that the lower bound for the 1-norm of accumulated regrets increases monotonically by adjusting the decision space at each iteration. This design is motivated by the observation that the range of step-sizes supporting the $O(1/T)$ convergence rate in existing smooth RM$^+$ variants is contingent on the lower bound for the 1-norm of accumulated regrets. Experimental results confirm that MI-SPRM$^+$ empirically attains an $O(1/T)$ convergence rate.

Computer Vision · Vision Models & Multimodal

Yuanxin Liu, Kun Ouyang, Haoning Wu, Yi Liu, Lin Sui, Xinhao Li, Yan Zhong, Y.Charles, Xinyu Zhou, Xu Sun

Recent studies have shown that long chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning can significantly enhance the performance of large language models (LLMs) on complex tasks. However, this benefit is yet to be demonstrated in the domain of video understanding, since most existing benchmarks lack the reasoning depth required to demonstrate the advantages of extended CoT chains. While recent efforts have proposed benchmarks aimed at video reasoning, the tasks are often knowledge-driven and do not rely heavily on visual content. To bridge this gap, we introduce **VideoReasonBench**, a benchmark designed to evaluate **vision-centric, complex video reasoning**. To ensure visual richness and high reasoning complexity, each video in VideoReasonBench depicts a sequence of fine-grained operations on a latent state that is only visible in part of the video. The questions evaluate three escalating levels of video reasoning skills: recalling observed visual information, inferring the content of latent states, and predicting information beyond the video. Under such task setting, models have to precisely recall multiple operations in the video, and perform step-by-step reasoning to get correct final answers for these questions. Using VideoReasonBench, we comprehensively evaluate 18 state-of-the-art multimodal LLMs (MLLMs), finding that most perform poorly on complex video reasoning—e.g., GPT-4o achieves only 6.9\% accuracy—while the thinking-enhanced Gemini-2.5-Pro significantly outperforms others with 56.0% accuracy. Our investigations on "test-time scaling" further reveal that extended thinking budget, while offering none or minimal benefits on existing video benchmarks, is essential for improving the performance on VideoReasonBench.

Theory · Learning Theory

Youssef Chaabouni, David Gamarnik

We study sparse recovery when observations come from mixed-quality sources: a small collection of high-quality measurements with small noise variance and a larger collection of lower-quality measurements with higher variance. For this heterogeneous-noise setting, we establish sample-size conditions for information-theoretic and algorithmic recovery. On the information-theoretic side, we show that it is sufficient for $(n_1, n_2)$ to satisfy a linear trade-off defining the _Price of Quality_: the number of low-quality samples needed to replace one high-quality sample. In the agnostic setting, where the decoder is completely agnostic to the quality of the data, it is uniformly bounded, and in particular one high-quality sample is never worth more than two low-quality samples for this sufficient condition to hold. In the informed setting, where the decoder is informed of per-sample variances, the price of quality can grow arbitrarily large. On the algorithmic side, we analyze the LASSO in the agnostic setting and show that the recovery threshold matches the homogeneous-noise case and only depends on the average noise level, revealing a striking robustness of computational recovery to data heterogeneity. Together, these results give the first conditions for sparse recovery with mixed-quality data and expose a fundamental difference between how the information-theoretic and algorithmic thresholds adapt to changes in data quality.

Rushi Qiang, Yuchen Zhuang, Anikait Singh, Percy Liang, Chao Zhang, Sherry Yang, Bo Dai

While Language Models (LMs) have made significant progress in automating machine learning engineering (MLE), the acquisition of high-quality MLE training data is significantly constrained. Current MLE benchmarks suffer from low scalability and limited applicability because they rely on static, manually curated tasks that demand extensive time and manual effort to produce. We introduce MLE-Smith, a fully automated multi-agent pipeline, to transform raw datasets into competition-style MLE challenges through an efficient generate--verify--execute paradigm for scaling MLE tasks with verifiable quality, real-world usability and rich diversity. The proposed multi-agent pipeline in MLE-Smith drives structured task design and standardized refactoring, coupled with a hybrid verification mechanism that enforces strict structural rules and high-level semantic soundness. It further validates empirical solvability and real-world fidelity through interactive execution. We apply MLE-Smith to 224 of real-world datasets and generates 606 tasks spanning multiple categories, objectives, and modalities, demonstrating that MLE-Smith can work effectively across a wide range of real-world datasets. Evaluation on generated tasks shows that the performance of eight mainstream and cutting-edge LLMs on MLE-Smith tasks is strongly correlated with their performance on carefully human-designed tasks, highlighting the effectiveness of the MLE-Smith in scaling up MLE tasks while maintaining task quality.

Applications · Robotics

Zhengxue Cheng, Yan Zhao, Keyu Wang, Hengdi ZHANG, Li Song

Tactile sensing is crucial for embodied intelligence, providing fine-grained perception and control in complex environments. However, efficient tactile data compression, which is essential for real-time robotic applications under strict bandwidth constraints, remains underexplored. The inherent heterogeneity and spatiotemporal complexity of tactile data further complicate this challenge. To bridge this gap, we introduce TaCo, the first comprehensive benchmark for Tactile data Codecs. TaCo evaluates 30 compression methods, including off-the-shelf compression algorithms and neural codecs, across five diverse datasets from various sensor types. We systematically assess both lossless and lossy compression schemes on four key tasks: lossless storage, human visualization, material and object classification, and dexterous robotic grasping. Notably, we pioneer the development of data-driven codecs explicitly trained on tactile data, TaCo-LL (lossless) and TaCo-L (lossy). Results have validated the superior performance of our TaCo-LL and TaCo-L. This benchmark provides a foundational framework for understanding the critical trade-offs between compression efficiency and task performance, paving the way for future advances in tactile perception.

Deep Learning · Algorithms

Mara Daniels, Philippe Rigollet

We introduce a highly expressive class of function approximators called *Splat Regression Models*. Model outputs are mixtures of heterogeneous and anisotropic bump functions, termed *splats*, each weighted by an output vector. The power of splat modeling lies in its ability to locally adjust the scale and direction of each splat, achieving both high interpretability and accuracy. Fitting splat models reduces to optimization over the space of mixing measures, which can be implemented using Wasserstein-Fisher-Rao gradient flows. As a byproduct, we recover the popular *Gaussian Splatting* methodology as a special case, providing a unified theoretical framework for this state-of-the-art technique that clearly disambiguates the inverse problem, the model, and the optimization algorithm. Through numerical experiments, we demonstrate that the resulting models and algorithms constitute a flexible and promising approach for solving diverse approximation, estimation, and inverse problems involving low-dimensional data.

Theory · Learning Theory

Lekai Chen, Ashutosh Trivedi, Alvaro Velasquez

Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed in human–AI collaborative decision-making systems, where they are expected to align precise formal representations with ambiguous natural language. However, their ad hoc strategies for resolving ambiguity often lead to hallucinations and inconsistencies. We formalize this setting via probabilistic Minimally Adequate Teachers (pMATs) that (i) answer membership queries with fixed but possibly flipped labels, and (ii) return valid counterexamples to hypothesis equivalence. We present **CAPAL** (**C**lass-query **A**ctive, **P**ersistent-noise-**A**ware **L**earning), an active algorithm for learning deterministic finite automata (DFAs) that remains correct under persistent membership noise without demonstrations. CAPAL augments the classic \$L^\star\$ loop with two components grounded in our implementation: (1) a *class query* realized as a statistical same-state test that compares disagreements between two prefixes against a noise-floor estimate \$\hat{\eta}\$ with Hoeffding tolerances; (2) a *discrimination tree* that selects a near-minimal discriminator, keeping the core suffix set small. An efficient micro-bootstrap and cache-reuse scheme estimates \$\hat{\eta}\$ with few new queries. We prove convergence given a perfect language-equivalence oracle and show substantial membership-query savings in practice. Our evaluation across multiple benchmarks, including RegexLib and KB13, demonstrates that this approach enhances both the efficiency and robustness of DFA learning under noisy oracles, supporting the view of LLMs as fallible yet useful collaborators for synthesizing verifiable formal artifacts.

Applications · Time Series

Ao Hu, Liangjian Wen, Jiang Duan, Yong Dai, HE YAN, Dongkai Wang, Jun Wang, Yukun Zhang, Ruoxi Jiang, Zenglin Xu

Long-term time series forecasting (LTSF) plays a crucial role in fields such as energy management, finance, and traffic prediction. Transformer-based models have adopted patch-based strategies to capture long-range dependencies, but accurately modeling shape similarities across patches and variables remains challenging due to scale differences. To address this, we introduce patch-mean decoupling (PMD), which separates the trend and residual shape information by subtracting the mean of each patch, preserving the original structure and ensuring that the attention mechanism captures true shape similarities. Futhermore, to more effectively model long-range dependencies and capture cross-variable relationships, we propose Trend Restoration Attention (TRA) and Proximal Variable Attention (PVA). The former module reintegrates the decoupled trend from PMD while calculating attention output. And the latter focuses cross-variable attention on the most relevant, recent time segments to avoid overfitting on outdated correlations. Combining these components, we propose PMDformer, a model designed to effectively capture shape similarity in long-term forecasting scenarios. Extensive experiments indicate that PMDformer outperforms existing state-of-the-art methods in stability and accuracy across multiple LTSF benchmarks. The code is available at https://github.com/aohu1105/PMDformer.

Deep Learning · Generative Models and Autoencoders

Roman Tarasov, Petr Mokrov, Milena Gazdieva, Evgeny Burnaev, Aleksandr Korotin

Neural network-based optimal transport (OT) is a recent and fruitful direction in the generative modeling community. It finds its applications in various fields such as domain translation, image super-resolution, computational biology and others. Among the existing OT approaches, of considerable interest are adversarial minimax solvers based on semi-dual formulations of OT problems. While promising, these methods lack theoretical investigation from a statistical learning perspective. Our work fills this gap by establishing upper bounds on the generalization error of an approximate OT map recovered by the minimax quadratic OT solver. Importantly, the bounds we derive depend solely on some standard statistical and mathematical properties of the considered functional classes (neural nets). While our analysis focuses on the quadratic OT, we believe that similar bounds could be derived for general OT case, paving the promising direction for future research. Our experimental illustrations are available online https://github.com/milenagazdieva/StatOT.

Kairong Luo, Zhenbo Sun, Haodong Wen, Xinyu Shi, Jiarui Cui, Chenyi Dang, Kaifeng Lyu, Wenguang Chen

Due to the scarcity of high-quality data, large language models (LLMs) are often trained on mixtures of data with varying quality levels, even after sophisticated data curation. A natural approach to better leverage high-quality data is curriculum-based pretraining, where the model is trained on data sorted in ascending order of quality as determined by a quality metric. However, prior studies have reported limited improvements from such curriculum-based pretraining strategies. This work identifies a critical factor constraining these methods: the incompatibility between the ascending data quality order and the decaying learning rate (LR) schedule. We find that while curriculum-based training substantially outperforms random shuffling when using a constant LR, its advantage diminishes under standard LR decay schedules. Our experiments show this incompatibility can be mitigated by two simple strategies: (1) employing a more moderate LR decay schedule, where the final LR is only moderately smaller than the peak LR, and (2) replacing LR decay with model averaging, i.e., computing a weighted average of the final few checkpoints. By combining these strategies, we improve the average score on a suite of standard benchmarks by 1.64% over random shuffling, without additional data refinement. Validated on 1.5B-parameter models trained over 30B tokens with various data-quality metrics, our findings call for a re-evaluation of curriculum-based LLM pretraining and underscore the potential of co-designing data curricula with optimization methods.

Sijie Ren, Meng Yan, Zhen Zhang, Xu Yinghui, Xinwei Sun

This paper aims to develop a lower prediction bound (LPB) for survival time across different treatments in the general right-censored setting. Although previous methods have utilized conformal prediction to construct the LPB, their resulting prediction sets provide only probably approximately correct (PAC)–type miscoverage guarantees rather than exact ones. To address this problem, we propose a new calibration procedure under the potential outcome framework. Under the strong ignorability assumption, we propose a reweighting scheme that can transform the problem into a weighted conformal inference problem, allowing an LPB to be obtained via quantile regression with an exact miscoverage guarantee. Furthermore, our procedure is doubly robust against model misspecification. Empirical evaluations on synthetic and real-world clinical data demonstrate the validity and informativeness of our constructed LPBs, which indicate the potential of our analytical benchmark for comparing and selecting personalized treatments.